By Richard Mertens
Patsy Hopper dreamed of a home in the country with a garden and lots of trees. What she didn’t count on were the herbicides that would come drifting in, year after year, from the farmland around her, killing vegetables in her garden and wildflowers in the ditches and curling the leaves of the trees she had planted.
“I have a lot of trees dying,” said Hopper, who lives five miles from Urbana, Illinois. “I don’t think they’ll survive.”
Hopper isn’t alone. A popular weed killer called dicamba, which is used in growing crops such as soybeans and cotton, has in recent years become notorious for inflicting widespread damage well beyond the fields where it is sprayed. Dicamba drift, as it’s called, has harmed other farmers’ crops, as well as vegetable gardens, orchards, and natural vegetation. The damage has spawned lawsuits and caused hard feelings in rural communities. It even led to the killing of an Arkansas farmer in 2016.
Farmers have used dicamba to kill weeds since the 1960s. But new formulations developed by Monsanto, BASF and Syngenta to be used with genetically engineered crops tolerant of dicamba wreaked havoc when they came into use roughly 8 years ago, largely because they encouraged farmers to spray dicamba after their crops sprouted. These formulations are marketed to be used ‘over the top’ (OTT) because they are sprayed on top of growing crops, killing weeds but not the genetically engineered crops.
The warm weather that typically accompanies crop growth makes dicamba more prone to volatilize and drift. And since the rollout of the new dicamba products and the OTT use, thousands of incidents of “off-target” damage have been recorded across many states, mostly in the South and Midwest. Millions of acres of soybeans have been damaged.
Last year, a US court banned the use of the dicamba OTT weed killers. Now, as farmers prepare for their next planting season, the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is again considering whether to grant approval to dicamba products used with dicamba-tolerant crops. The issue has divided rural communities and fostered heated debate.
Opponents want the use of OTT dicamba halted permanently. But many farmers say they need it. Agrochemical companies developed the dicamba system – new formulations of the herbicide to be used with crops engineered to tolerate it– as an alternative to Monsanto’s widely used chemical-crop system built around the weed killer glyphosate. Millions of acres now sprout weeds resistant to glyphosate, and many farmers say dicamba is among just a few herbicides that still work on the most troublesome weeds in their fields.
“It (dicamba) definitely is a big deal,” said Sam Whitaker, whose family grows rice, soybeans and cotton in Arkansas. “We need it.”